Page Content | Main Menu | Section Menu | Support Us | Contact Us
Center for Democracy and Technology
Working for Democratic Values in a Digital Age
Support CDT
Contact Us
PolicyBeta - Digital Policy in Process
This Section

Chertoff Disagrees with the Rest of His Agency, Again

April 16th, 2008 by Ari Schwartz

Nine days ago, Sophia Cope blogged about how Homeland Secretary Secretary Michael Chertoff suggested that REAL IDs cannot be skimmed, in sharp contrast to DHS REAL ID Regs, which clearly say that the REAL ID is at risk of skimming. Today, CDT Fellow Peter Swire blogged on the Center for American Progress Web site about a new Chertoff statement where he said that “fingerprints aren’t ‘Personal Data.’” Swire shows that this comment lies in sharp contrast to DHS’ stated policy that fingerprints are “personally identifiable information.”

It is now time for DHS to make clear, is Chertoff purposely suggesting changes to existing policy or are these both misstatements?


This entry was posted on Wednesday, April 16th, 2008 at 1:04 pm and is filed under CDT, Consumer Privacy, Security & Freedom. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Leave a Reply

About the Blog

    PolicyBeta is a forum for CDT experts to discuss news and developments in the technology policy arena. Visitors are encouraged to comment on the blog or email the authors.

    Our goal with PolicyBeta is to foster thoughtful discussion regarding technology policy as it relates to civil liberties and democratic values. While we encourage comments, we must insist that they be focused, relevant and written in a tone that is respectful of other posters. For more information, please feel free to contact PolicyBeta editor Brock Meeks.

    Check the main CDT site for complete, up-to-date information on CDT initiatives and activities.

Search Blog
       Top
Privacy Policy | Feedback